New York, May 15- In response to the announced takeover
of OshKosh B'Gosh Inc by Carter’s Inc, Beam Capital Management, LLC
announced today that it rejects the terms of the agreement valuing OshKosh
at $312 million dollars or $26 a share. “We believe that this takeover at
the current price is detrimental to the best interests of shareholders of
OshKosh” stated Mohannad Aama, Managing Director at Beam Capital Management
in New York. The market was clearly valuing shares of Oshkosh at around $30
as evidenced by the average trading price of the stock during the period
after the announcement that the company is effectively putting itself up for
sale back on February 17, 2005 and the announcement of the takeover on May
10, 2005.
“After backing out all of the company’s liabilities, we
conservatively estimate that Oshkosh has in excess of $200 million in cash
and tangible assets. The venerable century-old OshKosh brand name and
related trademarks generated $13 million in licensing and royalty income in
2004. This income stream alone is conservatively valued at between $100 and
$150 million. In essence, we have a company that is worth $300-$350 million
or $25-$29 a share before we even begin to value the actual business and
expertise of selling, making, sourcing, and designing children’s ware or the
great number of industry and trade relationships that OshKosh possesses”
added Mr. Aama. Even on a comparables basis, the current takeover price is
still lower than what other competitors are trading at be it on a Price to
Earnings P/E ratios or on a Price to Sales ratios.
Carter’s chairman and CEO Fred Rowan stated in the
takeover announcement that potential synergies will be realized “By
leveraging our proven brand management and supply chain skills, we
anticipate that the addition of OshKosh B'Gosh will create significant value
for Carter's shareholders” which, indeed, led the shares of Carter’s stock
to leap by 12% or an increase of more than $140 million in market value.
We believe that this far exceeds any potential synergies from "supply chain
skills" but rather it truly reflects the discounted price being paid
relative to the true value of Oshkosh shares. Selling the company at this
discounted price leads us to believe that either investors are yet to know
the whole story or that the Board of Directors succumbed to a heck of a
sales job by Carter’s and its bankers. In both events we urge our clients
and other investors of OshKosh to voice their concerns to the Board of
Directors of OshKosh and to unanimously reject the takeover bid at the
current depressed price. In lieu of the above and the actual trading price
of the company’s shares before the takeover announcement, it is really hard
to imagine how the Board of Directors came to the conclusion that this
takeover price is in the best interest of all shareholders.
Beam Capital Management is a registered investment
advisor based in New York. Although the firm does not own any shares of
Oshkosh, we have purchased the shares in client accounts over the past 12
months and we believe that we have a fiduciary duty to our clients to voice
our opinion against the proposed takeover at this price.
|